Why what others say about you elsewhere matters more to AI than your own site
Taking care of just your own site is only half the job. The other half happens in places you don't control directly.
In short
According to a Search Engine Land survey, 82% of citations made by generative AIs come from third-party sources, like press, directories and reviews, not from the business's own site. That changes how you should think about visibility: it's not enough to polish your own page, what others say about you matters just as much, if not more.
AI trusts what third parties say more
It makes sense if you think about it: when a friend recommends a restaurant, you trust that more than an ad from the restaurant itself. A generative AI works in a similar way. According to research from Search Engine Land, most citations made by assistants like ChatGPT and Gemini come from external sources, not content published by the business itself.
Source: Search Engine LandWhen a friend recommends a restaurant, you trust that more than an ad from the restaurant itself. A generative AI works in a similar way.
What counts as a third-party source
It's not just major press. Local directories, real customer reviews, coverage in regional outlets and even mentions on other sites in your industry all count as external signals. The more trustworthy places mention your business, the more confident AI feels recommending you.
What you can actually do about it
You don't need to become a press office. Start with the basics: make sure your presence is correct in relevant local directories, encourage real reviews and, when possible, look for mentions in outlets or blogs in your industry. Each consistent external mention adds to the same track record your own site builds on its own.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need to hire a press agency?
Not necessarily. A press agency is an option for those with budget, but the basics already help a lot: correct, complete presence in local directories, real reviews that get answered and, when possible, simple partnerships with other local businesses or outlets that might mention you.
Do reviews count as an external source?
Yes, and they count a lot. Real reviews on platforms like Google and social media are exactly the kind of third-party mention AI uses to build trust about a business, on top of also weighing directly on the rating, which on its own already influences the recommendation.
How do I know if there are already mentions of my business online?
A free MerbIQ scan shows, in 60 seconds, what ChatGPT, Gemini and other AIs already know about your business today, including whether they can find enough information to recommend you with confidence. It's a good starting point before spending time chasing new mentions.
Our take
This is discouraging for anyone who thinks all they need is a nice-looking website. But it's also good news: it means real customer reviews, local directory presence and being mentioned by other neighborhood businesses genuinely matter, and that's within reach of any small business, no expensive agency required.
See what AI already knows about your business today.
New content every week, straight to your inbox
A summary of what matters in AI, SEO, GEO and AEO, to help your business show up in the right answers. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
Keep reading
SEO & GEO/AEO
GEO and AEO: what's the difference and why your business needs both
Two new names, one shared goal: showing up when someone asks an AI.
SEO & GEO/AEO
How to structure your business content so AI cites it (instead of ignoring it)
It's not about writing more, it's about organizing what you already know in a way AI can actually use.
Tips for your business
Why your review rating could decide whether AI recommends you
The AIs recommend businesses with high ratings. And those who don't respond to reviews are practically invisible.